Third-Party Audits: How to Uncover the Skeletons in Your Vendor’s Closet

The postings on this site are my own and do not necessarily represent FTI Consulting’s positions, strategies or opinions.

Welcome back to the never-ending show that is Third-Party Risk Management! We’ve tackled vendor tantrums, navigated the pitfalls of incident response, and now it’s time to step into an even murkier arena: the third-party audit. Yes, today we’re donning our detective hats and diving deep into the hidden corners of your vendor’s operations—because who doesn’t love uncovering a good skeleton in the closet?

The Audit’s Dark Side: What You Don’t Know Can Hurt You

Let’s be honest—audits don’t exactly scream “fun.” They’re time-consuming, tedious, and often involve wading through more paperwork than a tax accountant in April. But here’s the thing: third-party audits are crucial. Why? Because vendors, like magicians, are great at misdirection. They’ll show you the shiny, polished surface while keeping the mess hidden just out of sight.

That’s where the audit comes in. It’s your chance to look behind the curtain, lift up the rug, and see what’s really going on. And trust me, what you find might not be pretty. But hey, better to know now than to be blindsided later, right?

The Skeleton Hunt: What Are You Looking For?

So, what exactly are you trying to uncover in these audits? Think of it as a treasure hunt, but instead of gold, you’re looking for risks, non-compliance, and other potential disasters waiting to happen. Here are a few common skeletons you might find:

1. Security Shortcomings: Remember when your vendor promised they had top-notch security measures? Well, an audit might reveal that their “state-of-the-art” defenses are more like a rusty chain-link fence. Outdated software, weak access controls, and unpatched vulnerabilities are just a few of the horrors you might uncover.
2. Compliance Gaps: Your vendor assured you they were compliant with all relevant regulations, but the audit says otherwise. Maybe they’re cutting corners on data protection, or maybe their “compliance” is more theoretical than practical. Either way, these gaps are ticking time bombs that could blow up in your face.
3. Financial Instability: No one likes to talk about money, but financial audits can reveal if your vendor is teetering on the edge of bankruptcy. Sudden changes in payment terms, unexplained financial losses, or dwindling cash reserves are red flags that your vendor might not be as financially stable as they claim.
4. Operational Inefficiencies: An audit can also shed light on how well—or poorly—your vendor is managing their operations. Missed deadlines, quality control issues, and overworked staff are signs that your vendor might be struggling to keep up with their commitments.

The Dance of the Audit: How to Do It Right

Now that you know what you’re looking for, let’s talk about how to conduct an audit without turning it into a full-blown witch hunt. The goal here is to be thorough without being overly aggressive. After all, you want to uncover issues, not burn bridges.

1. Set Clear Expectations: Before the audit begins, make sure your vendor knows what to expect. Outline the scope, objectives, and timeline of the audit so there are no surprises. The last thing you want is a vendor who feels ambushed and becomes defensive.
2. Collaborate, Don’t Confront: Approach the audit as a collaborative effort rather than a confrontation. Frame it as a way to ensure that both parties are on the same page and working towards the same goals. This approach can help maintain a positive relationship, even if you do uncover some skeletons.
3. Dig Deep, But Fairly: Be thorough in your investigation, but don’t go overboard. Focus on the areas that matter most—security, compliance, financial stability, and operational efficiency. Remember, the goal is to identify risks and address them, not to find fault for the sake of it.
4. Document Everything: As with any good detective work, documentation is key. Keep detailed records of what you find, including any discrepancies, non-compliance issues, or areas of concern. This documentation will be crucial if you need to escalate issues or take corrective action.

What to Do with the Skeletons You Find

So, you’ve uncovered some skeletons—now what? The next step is to work with your vendor to address the issues. Depending on the severity of what you find, this could involve anything from requesting corrective action to reconsidering the relationship altogether.

If the issues are minor and the vendor is willing to address them, great! Work together to fix the problems and strengthen the relationship moving forward. But if the skeletons are more like rotting corpses and the vendor is either unable or unwilling to change, it might be time to start looking for a new partner. After all, you don’t want to tie your company’s future to a vendor who’s dragging a graveyard behind them.

The Bottom Line: Audits Are Your Best Defense

In the end, third-party audits are your best defense against the unknown. They’re your chance to uncover risks before they become disasters, to ensure your vendor is living up to their promises, and to protect your business from the consequences of other people’s mistakes.

But as we all know, the world of risk management is constantly evolving, and staying ahead of the game requires more than just uncovering today’s risks—it means anticipating tomorrow’s. In my next post, I dive into “Predicting the Unpredictable: The Future of Third-Party Risks,” where we’ll explore the emerging threats on the horizon and how to prepare for the risks that haven’t even materialized yet.

Until then, keep those detective hats on, and remember: in the world of TPRM, it’s always better to find the skeletons before they find you. 🎪

See you in the next act!